All posts
Four tactics to disrupt complacent groups and build creative teams
Dave Winsborough
Created on
July 11, 2023

“Wayne, you are wrong, wrong, wrong and here’s why.”

If you overheard these words at an offsite retreat for the executive leadership team of your organisation what would it tell you about the chances for the firm? Would you start looking for a job? Because clearly they can’t get along and are going to crash the company as they fight for control.

As a leadership coach I’d be quietly delighted. I have been very lucky in my career to coach a fair number of leadership teams. I particularly recall my first, the fractious group of executives who ran Wang Labs NZ, a company whose US parent went into Chapter 11 bankruptcy a month or two after I started.

The good news is that over the next five years the team succeeded in completely reinventing the NZ business, which thrived before being acquired. But the journey was acrimonious, intense, nearly violent, and yet at the same time very often loving.

The team shared a deeply felt mission to save something bigger than any one of them, preserve the livelihoods of staff and ultimately win. They argued, talked, held each other to account and jollied each other along when things were tough. It produced a deeply committed, fully lived, collective effort. I assumed that all senior teams would be like that.

Since then, with the 30 or so teams I’ve personally worked with, the reality is very different (particularly in government organisations). Unclear goals, haphazard performance tracking, indecision, polite passivity, patch-protection and decision relitigation are closer to the norm. I’ve observed that’s because in large part team members work very hard to get along with each other and even harder at not rocking the boat or upsetting someone else’s feelings. I should be clear though: Harmony on the team does not lead to high performance.

Studies confirm my Wang Labs experience: Winning exerts a stronger influence on cohesion than cohesion has on performance. Many teams seem to be governed more by don’ts than do’s: Don’t rock the boat, don’t offend the boss by challenging their thinking, don’t admit mistakes; don’t take a decision; don’t be held to account. For a hilariously real example watch the BBC show Twenty Twelve.

Group harmony isn’t wrong, per se. More than one study has found that teams who get along with each other positively affects sports team performance. But only up to a point. Teams who never challenge each other end up in what is termed “groupthink” which limits the creativity of the group.

But how to disrupt complacent, overly agreeable teams and build a powerful, creative team? Try these four tactics.

Increase Diversity

One finding is that those firms with a higher proportion of female managers had higher returns on equity and sales that male only firms.

McKinsey found that publicly traded European companies are more successful when their management and boards are more diverse. Teams who are cognitively diverse – differing personalities and value sets - produce more ideas.

Increase uncertainty

Research has shown that task uncertainty actually generates more ideas. Rather than starting with a defined task or action, start with a series of questions. Or imagine an almost impossible end-state and start discussing the paths to get there.

Limit resources

Success and happiness pose a bigger threat to businesses than a moderate degree of dissatisfaction or hardship.

Teams are often more creative when they have fewer resources rather than more. Resources can be tangible, like money, people and tools. But it can also mean time – the 48 hour film festival or software company Atlassian’s hackathons show that working to crazy deadlines means the normal way of doing things can be reinvented.

Psychological safety isn’t an end, it’s a means

Most significant innovation in the history of civilization have been the product of dissatisfied minds: People who were unhappy with the current order of things and sought to disrupt.

Good leaders create environments where it is safe to speak out and challenge. Explicit processes can help: Some militaries role play as hostile forces in order to expose their own weaknesses (called red teaming). In our work on large infrastructure projects Winsborough consultants frequently use a pre-mortem, imagining a future in which the project failed, and then working backwards to address those problems in our current day planning.

Ant Howard, the CEO of Wang, liked to point out that any leadership team looks good when things are going well, but that great teams were only revealed when things go pear shaped.

Start learning to fight now.

Note: This article was originally published in

Recent posts
News & Press
Introducing the Deeper Signals Platform for Coaches, built for the modern coach.
Coaching is not an easy job. The industry is booming, making it difficult to stand out. Coaches are striving to scale their business and deliver increased impact for their clients. Traditional coaching tools have failed to keep pace.
Read more
News & Press
The Seven Senseless Myths about Personality
The field of personality science delves into the multifaceted dimensions that shape an individual's character, influencing their thoughts, emotions, and behaviors. Despite its profound significance in understanding human nature, personality often remains shrouded in misconceptions and oversimplifications. There is solid science, but it’s largely ignored. In this article we call out and debunk seven common myths based on the latest research.
Read more
DynaMo 2.0: Data-driven coaching sprints for all employees
Our newest update to the Deeper Signals Platform means every employee can receive personalized coaching advice and embark on curated development sprints to help them grow and thrive at work.
Read more
Curious to learn more?

Schedule a call with Deeper Signals to understand how our assessments and feedback tools help people gain a deep awareness of their talents and reach their full potential. Underpinned by science and technology, we build talented people, leaders and companies.

  • Scalable and engaging assessment solutions
  • Measurable and predictive talent insights
  • Powered by technology and science that drives results
Let's talk!
  • Scalable interventions for growth
  • Measureable data, insights and outcomes for high performance
  • Proven scientific expertise that links results to outcomes
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Please fill all fields before submiting the form.