All posts

Why you need more team players, and fewer stars

Author
Dave Winsborough
Created on
May 5, 2025

No matter where you work, it is a fair bet that you have to cooperate with others on a team. There is no rule that says you have to like your teammates, but for a team to succeed there are some basic principles everyone needs to follow:

  1. Put the team’s interests ahead of your own.
  2. Pull your weight and do your job to the best of your ability.
  3. Channel your competitive spirit to beat the opposition, not your teammates.

But there have always been people on teams, regardless of ability, who demonstrate a dysfunctional quality that sours relationships and disrupts team performance.

For example, English footballer John Terry was a highly skilled and courageous player on the field. He captained Chelsea to a record five premier league titles, and also lead the English team.  Off the field however, he was known for starting fights in bars, jumping queues, hogging disabled carparks, blaming teammates for his own mistakes and racially abusing colleagues. And he reportedly had an affair with the wife of a teammate, which cost him the captaincy of England for the second time.

But being a good teammate is not simply the opposite of bad.  

Science shows us that there are four behaviors and three character traits that make the best team players:

  1. The best team players collaborate and cooperate with colleagues. That is, they pool their ideas, information, and efforts with others to achieve tasks. They say things like “how do we crack this problem together”.
  2. Great teammates act altruistically — they put themselves out to help colleagues, and do things that further the team’s interest rather than their own. It shows up as “I can see you have a lot on – can I help out?”.
  3. Really good colleagues show their positive appreciation for the team and the efforts that others have made. It is as simple as “Really terrific work – you guys knocked it out of the park”.
  4. Teammates you can rely on make sure they do what they say they will, to the best of their capabilities. They front up, day after day, and do their own hard work.

Temperament also has an impact of the kind of team player you will be, and research shows the personality makeup of the team affects its performance. For example:

  1. Teams with more emotionally stable members tend to do better. That’s because passionate and volatile teammates leak negativity and heighten tensions.
  2. Being conscientious and reliable is valued by colleagues (as opposed to being sloppy and haphazard). People who show integrity, have high standards and stick to the rules are good to have on the team.
  3. Being socially skilled, warm and caring also makes for improved team cohesion. Those who care what happens to their teammates and how they are feeling, help create bonds and boost other's wellbeing.

Talented stars are great to have, but teams of stars don’t always make for the best team. Good teammates who you can trust to have your back in a tight spot matter just as much.

What sort of teammate are you?  Find out with Deeper Signals. Or help your team with a Team Sprint

All posts

Why you need more team players, and fewer stars

Author
Dave Winsborough
Created on

No matter where you work, it is a fair bet that you have to cooperate with others on a team. There is no rule that says you have to like your teammates, but for a team to succeed there are some basic principles everyone needs to follow:

  1. Put the team’s interests ahead of your own.
  2. Pull your weight and do your job to the best of your ability.
  3. Channel your competitive spirit to beat the opposition, not your teammates.

But there have always been people on teams, regardless of ability, who demonstrate a dysfunctional quality that sours relationships and disrupts team performance.

For example, English footballer John Terry was a highly skilled and courageous player on the field. He captained Chelsea to a record five premier league titles, and also lead the English team.  Off the field however, he was known for starting fights in bars, jumping queues, hogging disabled carparks, blaming teammates for his own mistakes and racially abusing colleagues. And he reportedly had an affair with the wife of a teammate, which cost him the captaincy of England for the second time.

But being a good teammate is not simply the opposite of bad.  

Science shows us that there are four behaviors and three character traits that make the best team players:

  1. The best team players collaborate and cooperate with colleagues. That is, they pool their ideas, information, and efforts with others to achieve tasks. They say things like “how do we crack this problem together”.
  2. Great teammates act altruistically — they put themselves out to help colleagues, and do things that further the team’s interest rather than their own. It shows up as “I can see you have a lot on – can I help out?”.
  3. Really good colleagues show their positive appreciation for the team and the efforts that others have made. It is as simple as “Really terrific work – you guys knocked it out of the park”.
  4. Teammates you can rely on make sure they do what they say they will, to the best of their capabilities. They front up, day after day, and do their own hard work.

Temperament also has an impact of the kind of team player you will be, and research shows the personality makeup of the team affects its performance. For example:

  1. Teams with more emotionally stable members tend to do better. That’s because passionate and volatile teammates leak negativity and heighten tensions.
  2. Being conscientious and reliable is valued by colleagues (as opposed to being sloppy and haphazard). People who show integrity, have high standards and stick to the rules are good to have on the team.
  3. Being socially skilled, warm and caring also makes for improved team cohesion. Those who care what happens to their teammates and how they are feeling, help create bonds and boost other's wellbeing.

Talented stars are great to have, but teams of stars don’t always make for the best team. Good teammates who you can trust to have your back in a tight spot matter just as much.

What sort of teammate are you?  Find out with Deeper Signals. Or help your team with a Team Sprint

All posts

Why you need more team players, and fewer stars

Author
Dave Winsborough
Created on
May 5, 2025

No matter where you work, it is a fair bet that you have to cooperate with others on a team. There is no rule that says you have to like your teammates, but for a team to succeed there are some basic principles everyone needs to follow:

  1. Put the team’s interests ahead of your own.
  2. Pull your weight and do your job to the best of your ability.
  3. Channel your competitive spirit to beat the opposition, not your teammates.

But there have always been people on teams, regardless of ability, who demonstrate a dysfunctional quality that sours relationships and disrupts team performance.

For example, English footballer John Terry was a highly skilled and courageous player on the field. He captained Chelsea to a record five premier league titles, and also lead the English team.  Off the field however, he was known for starting fights in bars, jumping queues, hogging disabled carparks, blaming teammates for his own mistakes and racially abusing colleagues. And he reportedly had an affair with the wife of a teammate, which cost him the captaincy of England for the second time.

But being a good teammate is not simply the opposite of bad.  

Science shows us that there are four behaviors and three character traits that make the best team players:

  1. The best team players collaborate and cooperate with colleagues. That is, they pool their ideas, information, and efforts with others to achieve tasks. They say things like “how do we crack this problem together”.
  2. Great teammates act altruistically — they put themselves out to help colleagues, and do things that further the team’s interest rather than their own. It shows up as “I can see you have a lot on – can I help out?”.
  3. Really good colleagues show their positive appreciation for the team and the efforts that others have made. It is as simple as “Really terrific work – you guys knocked it out of the park”.
  4. Teammates you can rely on make sure they do what they say they will, to the best of their capabilities. They front up, day after day, and do their own hard work.

Temperament also has an impact of the kind of team player you will be, and research shows the personality makeup of the team affects its performance. For example:

  1. Teams with more emotionally stable members tend to do better. That’s because passionate and volatile teammates leak negativity and heighten tensions.
  2. Being conscientious and reliable is valued by colleagues (as opposed to being sloppy and haphazard). People who show integrity, have high standards and stick to the rules are good to have on the team.
  3. Being socially skilled, warm and caring also makes for improved team cohesion. Those who care what happens to their teammates and how they are feeling, help create bonds and boost other's wellbeing.

Talented stars are great to have, but teams of stars don’t always make for the best team. Good teammates who you can trust to have your back in a tight spot matter just as much.

What sort of teammate are you?  Find out with Deeper Signals. Or help your team with a Team Sprint

All posts

Why you need more team players, and fewer stars

Author
Dave Winsborough
Created on
May 5, 2025

No matter where you work, it is a fair bet that you have to cooperate with others on a team. There is no rule that says you have to like your teammates, but for a team to succeed there are some basic principles everyone needs to follow:

  1. Put the team’s interests ahead of your own.
  2. Pull your weight and do your job to the best of your ability.
  3. Channel your competitive spirit to beat the opposition, not your teammates.

But there have always been people on teams, regardless of ability, who demonstrate a dysfunctional quality that sours relationships and disrupts team performance.

For example, English footballer John Terry was a highly skilled and courageous player on the field. He captained Chelsea to a record five premier league titles, and also lead the English team.  Off the field however, he was known for starting fights in bars, jumping queues, hogging disabled carparks, blaming teammates for his own mistakes and racially abusing colleagues. And he reportedly had an affair with the wife of a teammate, which cost him the captaincy of England for the second time.

But being a good teammate is not simply the opposite of bad.  

Science shows us that there are four behaviors and three character traits that make the best team players:

  1. The best team players collaborate and cooperate with colleagues. That is, they pool their ideas, information, and efforts with others to achieve tasks. They say things like “how do we crack this problem together”.
  2. Great teammates act altruistically — they put themselves out to help colleagues, and do things that further the team’s interest rather than their own. It shows up as “I can see you have a lot on – can I help out?”.
  3. Really good colleagues show their positive appreciation for the team and the efforts that others have made. It is as simple as “Really terrific work – you guys knocked it out of the park”.
  4. Teammates you can rely on make sure they do what they say they will, to the best of their capabilities. They front up, day after day, and do their own hard work.

Temperament also has an impact of the kind of team player you will be, and research shows the personality makeup of the team affects its performance. For example:

  1. Teams with more emotionally stable members tend to do better. That’s because passionate and volatile teammates leak negativity and heighten tensions.
  2. Being conscientious and reliable is valued by colleagues (as opposed to being sloppy and haphazard). People who show integrity, have high standards and stick to the rules are good to have on the team.
  3. Being socially skilled, warm and caring also makes for improved team cohesion. Those who care what happens to their teammates and how they are feeling, help create bonds and boost other's wellbeing.

Talented stars are great to have, but teams of stars don’t always make for the best team. Good teammates who you can trust to have your back in a tight spot matter just as much.

What sort of teammate are you?  Find out with Deeper Signals. Or help your team with a Team Sprint

All posts

Why you need more team players, and fewer stars

Customer
Job Title

No matter where you work, it is a fair bet that you have to cooperate with others on a team. There is no rule that says you have to like your teammates, but for a team to succeed there are some basic principles everyone needs to follow:

  1. Put the team’s interests ahead of your own.
  2. Pull your weight and do your job to the best of your ability.
  3. Channel your competitive spirit to beat the opposition, not your teammates.

But there have always been people on teams, regardless of ability, who demonstrate a dysfunctional quality that sours relationships and disrupts team performance.

For example, English footballer John Terry was a highly skilled and courageous player on the field. He captained Chelsea to a record five premier league titles, and also lead the English team.  Off the field however, he was known for starting fights in bars, jumping queues, hogging disabled carparks, blaming teammates for his own mistakes and racially abusing colleagues. And he reportedly had an affair with the wife of a teammate, which cost him the captaincy of England for the second time.

But being a good teammate is not simply the opposite of bad.  

Science shows us that there are four behaviors and three character traits that make the best team players:

  1. The best team players collaborate and cooperate with colleagues. That is, they pool their ideas, information, and efforts with others to achieve tasks. They say things like “how do we crack this problem together”.
  2. Great teammates act altruistically — they put themselves out to help colleagues, and do things that further the team’s interest rather than their own. It shows up as “I can see you have a lot on – can I help out?”.
  3. Really good colleagues show their positive appreciation for the team and the efforts that others have made. It is as simple as “Really terrific work – you guys knocked it out of the park”.
  4. Teammates you can rely on make sure they do what they say they will, to the best of their capabilities. They front up, day after day, and do their own hard work.

Temperament also has an impact of the kind of team player you will be, and research shows the personality makeup of the team affects its performance. For example:

  1. Teams with more emotionally stable members tend to do better. That’s because passionate and volatile teammates leak negativity and heighten tensions.
  2. Being conscientious and reliable is valued by colleagues (as opposed to being sloppy and haphazard). People who show integrity, have high standards and stick to the rules are good to have on the team.
  3. Being socially skilled, warm and caring also makes for improved team cohesion. Those who care what happens to their teammates and how they are feeling, help create bonds and boost other's wellbeing.

Talented stars are great to have, but teams of stars don’t always make for the best team. Good teammates who you can trust to have your back in a tight spot matter just as much.

What sort of teammate are you?  Find out with Deeper Signals. Or help your team with a Team Sprint

Ready for your Spotlight?
Contact us to book your Customer Spotlight and showcase your work to an extensive, global audience!
Start your free trial today
Free access to Deeper Signals’ quick, scientific assessments, feedback tools, and more.
Start Free Trial
Recent posts
Articles
What Does Your Hiring Process Signal to Candidates?
A hiring process is a two-way evaluation. While you read candidates, they're reading you. Here is what the research says about designing hiring that wins the candidates you actually want.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Turn Executive Assessment Data into a Leadership Narrative with an AI Skill
Psychometrics, 360s, interviews, references — this free Deeper Signals skill codes it all against a role's success criteria into an auditable leadership narrative.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Review an Assessment's Evidence Base with an AI Skill
How well is that assessment actually evidenced? This free Deeper Signals AI skill maps any instrument against the APA, SIOP, EFPA, and ITC standards.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Create a Coaching Plan from Assessment Results in Under 10 Minutes
Learn how Deeper Signals' free Development Plan skill turns assessment results into a coach-ready plan in under 10 minutes.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Build a Finance-Ready Business Case with the Assessment ROI Calculator
See how Deeper Signals' free Assessment ROI Calculator turns a few workforce data points into a finance-ready business case for assessment investment.
Read more
Want more articles like this?
Subscribe to our newsletter
Practical insights on people and performance, delivered to your inbox
Subscribe
Recent posts
Articles
What Does Your Hiring Process Signal to Candidates?
A hiring process is a two-way evaluation. While you read candidates, they're reading you. Here is what the research says about designing hiring that wins the candidates you actually want.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Turn Executive Assessment Data into a Leadership Narrative with an AI Skill
Psychometrics, 360s, interviews, references — this free Deeper Signals skill codes it all against a role's success criteria into an auditable leadership narrative.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Review an Assessment's Evidence Base with an AI Skill
How well is that assessment actually evidenced? This free Deeper Signals AI skill maps any instrument against the APA, SIOP, EFPA, and ITC standards.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Create a Coaching Plan from Assessment Results in Under 10 Minutes
Learn how Deeper Signals' free Development Plan skill turns assessment results into a coach-ready plan in under 10 minutes.
Read more
Guides & Tips
How to Build a Finance-Ready Business Case with the Assessment ROI Calculator
See how Deeper Signals' free Assessment ROI Calculator turns a few workforce data points into a finance-ready business case for assessment investment.
Read more
Curious to learn more?

Schedule a call with Deeper Signals to understand how our assessments and feedback tools help people gain a deep awareness of their talents and reach their full potential. Underpinned by science and technology, we build talented people, leaders and companies.

  • Scalable and engaging assessment solutions
  • Measurable and predictive talent insights
  • Powered by technology and science that drives results
Let's talk!
  • Scalable interventions for growth
  • Measurable data, insights and outcomes for high performance
  • Proven scientific expertise that links results to outcomes
Thank you!
Would you like to schedule a meeting?
Please fill all fields before submitting the form.